Accuracy of citation and quotation in foot and ankle surgery journals

Ma Luo, Charles Chuan Li, Domingo Molina IV, Clark R. Andersen, Vinod Panchbhavi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: A recent review of technical editing of research suggests that over one third of references cited in articles in medical journals have some inaccuracies and one fifth of quotations to references in these articles are not accurate. Methods: Two hundred and forty-nine citation references and 408 quotes from 25 articles published in 5 orthopaedic journals were randomly selected to determine referencing accuracy. The presence of citation errors was examined by 1 of the authors while the presence of quotation errors was determined by 2 of the authors. Full copies of articles as well as the references were obtained to compare the accuracies. Results: The total citation error rate was 41% (103 out of 249 references), and the total quotation error rate was 20% (80 out of 408 quotes) for the 5 orthopaedic journals. Conclusion: Citation and quotation errors were still relatively common in orthopaedic journals. While we did not identify any factors associated with citation and quotation errors, the use of technical editing may reduce the amount of citation errors. Clinical Relevance: Readers and authors should be aware that many citations of studies are inaccurate and one should review the original source if it is to be used in another publication or to guide clinical treatment.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)949-955
Number of pages7
JournalFoot and Ankle International
Volume34
Issue number7
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 2013

Fingerprint

Ankle
Foot
Orthopedics
Publications
Research

Keywords

  • Citation error
  • Quotation error
  • Reference accuracy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery
  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

Cite this

Accuracy of citation and quotation in foot and ankle surgery journals. / Luo, Ma; Li, Charles Chuan; Molina IV, Domingo; Andersen, Clark R.; Panchbhavi, Vinod.

In: Foot and Ankle International, Vol. 34, No. 7, 07.2013, p. 949-955.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Luo, Ma ; Li, Charles Chuan ; Molina IV, Domingo ; Andersen, Clark R. ; Panchbhavi, Vinod. / Accuracy of citation and quotation in foot and ankle surgery journals. In: Foot and Ankle International. 2013 ; Vol. 34, No. 7. pp. 949-955.
@article{2d0289adce23478d9544bca4f1801dcf,
title = "Accuracy of citation and quotation in foot and ankle surgery journals",
abstract = "Background: A recent review of technical editing of research suggests that over one third of references cited in articles in medical journals have some inaccuracies and one fifth of quotations to references in these articles are not accurate. Methods: Two hundred and forty-nine citation references and 408 quotes from 25 articles published in 5 orthopaedic journals were randomly selected to determine referencing accuracy. The presence of citation errors was examined by 1 of the authors while the presence of quotation errors was determined by 2 of the authors. Full copies of articles as well as the references were obtained to compare the accuracies. Results: The total citation error rate was 41{\%} (103 out of 249 references), and the total quotation error rate was 20{\%} (80 out of 408 quotes) for the 5 orthopaedic journals. Conclusion: Citation and quotation errors were still relatively common in orthopaedic journals. While we did not identify any factors associated with citation and quotation errors, the use of technical editing may reduce the amount of citation errors. Clinical Relevance: Readers and authors should be aware that many citations of studies are inaccurate and one should review the original source if it is to be used in another publication or to guide clinical treatment.",
keywords = "Citation error, Quotation error, Reference accuracy",
author = "Ma Luo and Li, {Charles Chuan} and {Molina IV}, Domingo and Andersen, {Clark R.} and Vinod Panchbhavi",
year = "2013",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1177/1071100713475354",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "34",
pages = "949--955",
journal = "Foot and Ankle International",
issn = "1071-1007",
publisher = "AOFAS - American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Accuracy of citation and quotation in foot and ankle surgery journals

AU - Luo, Ma

AU - Li, Charles Chuan

AU - Molina IV, Domingo

AU - Andersen, Clark R.

AU - Panchbhavi, Vinod

PY - 2013/7

Y1 - 2013/7

N2 - Background: A recent review of technical editing of research suggests that over one third of references cited in articles in medical journals have some inaccuracies and one fifth of quotations to references in these articles are not accurate. Methods: Two hundred and forty-nine citation references and 408 quotes from 25 articles published in 5 orthopaedic journals were randomly selected to determine referencing accuracy. The presence of citation errors was examined by 1 of the authors while the presence of quotation errors was determined by 2 of the authors. Full copies of articles as well as the references were obtained to compare the accuracies. Results: The total citation error rate was 41% (103 out of 249 references), and the total quotation error rate was 20% (80 out of 408 quotes) for the 5 orthopaedic journals. Conclusion: Citation and quotation errors were still relatively common in orthopaedic journals. While we did not identify any factors associated with citation and quotation errors, the use of technical editing may reduce the amount of citation errors. Clinical Relevance: Readers and authors should be aware that many citations of studies are inaccurate and one should review the original source if it is to be used in another publication or to guide clinical treatment.

AB - Background: A recent review of technical editing of research suggests that over one third of references cited in articles in medical journals have some inaccuracies and one fifth of quotations to references in these articles are not accurate. Methods: Two hundred and forty-nine citation references and 408 quotes from 25 articles published in 5 orthopaedic journals were randomly selected to determine referencing accuracy. The presence of citation errors was examined by 1 of the authors while the presence of quotation errors was determined by 2 of the authors. Full copies of articles as well as the references were obtained to compare the accuracies. Results: The total citation error rate was 41% (103 out of 249 references), and the total quotation error rate was 20% (80 out of 408 quotes) for the 5 orthopaedic journals. Conclusion: Citation and quotation errors were still relatively common in orthopaedic journals. While we did not identify any factors associated with citation and quotation errors, the use of technical editing may reduce the amount of citation errors. Clinical Relevance: Readers and authors should be aware that many citations of studies are inaccurate and one should review the original source if it is to be used in another publication or to guide clinical treatment.

KW - Citation error

KW - Quotation error

KW - Reference accuracy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84883002536&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84883002536&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/1071100713475354

DO - 10.1177/1071100713475354

M3 - Article

C2 - 23696189

AN - SCOPUS:84883002536

VL - 34

SP - 949

EP - 955

JO - Foot and Ankle International

JF - Foot and Ankle International

SN - 1071-1007

IS - 7

ER -