An assessment of overutilization and underutilization of laboratory tests by expert physicians in the evaluation of patients for bleeding and thrombotic disorders in clinical context and in real time

Mayukh K. Sarkar, Chad M. Botz, Michael Laposata

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Diagnostic error is extremely common in the USA and likely around the world. A major reason for the diagnostic error is both the overutilization and the underutilization of laboratory tests. Using a panel of two to four experts in coagulation, test selection was reviewed in clinical context and in real time, and consensus determinations were made to derive conclusions about the extent of overutilization and underutilization.

METHODS: Two hundred cases of patients being evaluated for bleeding or thrombotic issues were presented at each daily meeting of the diagnostic management team, and a review of each case for appropriate utilization of tests was completed.

RESULTS: Two hundred randomly selected cases revealed 77.5% diagnostic errors (155 cases). Sixteen percent were associated with overutilization of laboratory tests, 44% were associated with underutilization, and 17.5% were associated with both. The annual cost burden estimated for overutilization alone in one institution of 450 beds was on the order of $20,000. The cost burden for the delay in diagnosis or the misdiagnosis in cases with underutilization is orders of magnitude greater ($200,000 or more), but it is impossible to determine the cost of a misdiagnosis in an individual case because it can produce many different clinical outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS: This was a rare opportunity for experts in a given field to review cases in real time and in clinical context and provide immediately a consensus answer about test utilization. The results of this study show errors in test selection in nearly 75% of the cases evaluated.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)21-26
Number of pages6
JournalDiagnosis (Berlin, Germany)
Volume4
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2017

Fingerprint

Diagnostic Errors
Hemorrhage
Physicians
Costs and Cost Analysis
Costs
Coagulation

Keywords

  • coagulation
  • laboratory test selection
  • overutilization
  • underutilization

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine (miscellaneous)
  • Health Policy
  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health
  • Clinical Biochemistry
  • Biochemistry, medical

Cite this

@article{4248be93f552493db5d1f0ce75c227cf,
title = "An assessment of overutilization and underutilization of laboratory tests by expert physicians in the evaluation of patients for bleeding and thrombotic disorders in clinical context and in real time",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Diagnostic error is extremely common in the USA and likely around the world. A major reason for the diagnostic error is both the overutilization and the underutilization of laboratory tests. Using a panel of two to four experts in coagulation, test selection was reviewed in clinical context and in real time, and consensus determinations were made to derive conclusions about the extent of overutilization and underutilization.METHODS: Two hundred cases of patients being evaluated for bleeding or thrombotic issues were presented at each daily meeting of the diagnostic management team, and a review of each case for appropriate utilization of tests was completed.RESULTS: Two hundred randomly selected cases revealed 77.5{\%} diagnostic errors (155 cases). Sixteen percent were associated with overutilization of laboratory tests, 44{\%} were associated with underutilization, and 17.5{\%} were associated with both. The annual cost burden estimated for overutilization alone in one institution of 450 beds was on the order of $20,000. The cost burden for the delay in diagnosis or the misdiagnosis in cases with underutilization is orders of magnitude greater ($200,000 or more), but it is impossible to determine the cost of a misdiagnosis in an individual case because it can produce many different clinical outcomes.CONCLUSIONS: This was a rare opportunity for experts in a given field to review cases in real time and in clinical context and provide immediately a consensus answer about test utilization. The results of this study show errors in test selection in nearly 75{\%} of the cases evaluated.",
keywords = "coagulation, laboratory test selection, overutilization, underutilization",
author = "Sarkar, {Mayukh K.} and Botz, {Chad M.} and Michael Laposata",
year = "2017",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1515/dx-2016-0042",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "4",
pages = "21--26",
journal = "Diagnosis",
issn = "2194-8011",
publisher = "Hindawi Limited",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - An assessment of overutilization and underutilization of laboratory tests by expert physicians in the evaluation of patients for bleeding and thrombotic disorders in clinical context and in real time

AU - Sarkar, Mayukh K.

AU - Botz, Chad M.

AU - Laposata, Michael

PY - 2017/3/1

Y1 - 2017/3/1

N2 - BACKGROUND: Diagnostic error is extremely common in the USA and likely around the world. A major reason for the diagnostic error is both the overutilization and the underutilization of laboratory tests. Using a panel of two to four experts in coagulation, test selection was reviewed in clinical context and in real time, and consensus determinations were made to derive conclusions about the extent of overutilization and underutilization.METHODS: Two hundred cases of patients being evaluated for bleeding or thrombotic issues were presented at each daily meeting of the diagnostic management team, and a review of each case for appropriate utilization of tests was completed.RESULTS: Two hundred randomly selected cases revealed 77.5% diagnostic errors (155 cases). Sixteen percent were associated with overutilization of laboratory tests, 44% were associated with underutilization, and 17.5% were associated with both. The annual cost burden estimated for overutilization alone in one institution of 450 beds was on the order of $20,000. The cost burden for the delay in diagnosis or the misdiagnosis in cases with underutilization is orders of magnitude greater ($200,000 or more), but it is impossible to determine the cost of a misdiagnosis in an individual case because it can produce many different clinical outcomes.CONCLUSIONS: This was a rare opportunity for experts in a given field to review cases in real time and in clinical context and provide immediately a consensus answer about test utilization. The results of this study show errors in test selection in nearly 75% of the cases evaluated.

AB - BACKGROUND: Diagnostic error is extremely common in the USA and likely around the world. A major reason for the diagnostic error is both the overutilization and the underutilization of laboratory tests. Using a panel of two to four experts in coagulation, test selection was reviewed in clinical context and in real time, and consensus determinations were made to derive conclusions about the extent of overutilization and underutilization.METHODS: Two hundred cases of patients being evaluated for bleeding or thrombotic issues were presented at each daily meeting of the diagnostic management team, and a review of each case for appropriate utilization of tests was completed.RESULTS: Two hundred randomly selected cases revealed 77.5% diagnostic errors (155 cases). Sixteen percent were associated with overutilization of laboratory tests, 44% were associated with underutilization, and 17.5% were associated with both. The annual cost burden estimated for overutilization alone in one institution of 450 beds was on the order of $20,000. The cost burden for the delay in diagnosis or the misdiagnosis in cases with underutilization is orders of magnitude greater ($200,000 or more), but it is impossible to determine the cost of a misdiagnosis in an individual case because it can produce many different clinical outcomes.CONCLUSIONS: This was a rare opportunity for experts in a given field to review cases in real time and in clinical context and provide immediately a consensus answer about test utilization. The results of this study show errors in test selection in nearly 75% of the cases evaluated.

KW - coagulation

KW - laboratory test selection

KW - overutilization

KW - underutilization

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85014364375&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85014364375&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1515/dx-2016-0042

DO - 10.1515/dx-2016-0042

M3 - Article

VL - 4

SP - 21

EP - 26

JO - Diagnosis

JF - Diagnosis

SN - 2194-8011

IS - 1

ER -