Can Syndesmosis Screws Displace the Distal Fibula?

Background. There has been historical debate as to whether the distal tibiofibular syndesmosis can be overtightened during operative fixation. We used finite-element analysis to determine if overtightening of syndesmotic screws can cause widening of the lateral gutter clear space in the ankle joint. Methods. A 3D finite-element model was constructed and analyzed using geometries from a computed tomography scan of a cadaveric lower leg. Starting 2 cm from the plafond, screw fixation was simulated at 5-mm increments to a distance of 5 cm from the plafond. The fibula was compressed 2 mm toward the tibia at each interval, and the change in distance between the lateral talus and distal fibula was measured. Results. Medial deflection of the fibula resulted in widening of the lateral clear space, which was proportional to the amount of deflection. The effect increased as screws were placed closer to the plafond, with 1.5 mm of widening at 2 cm (0.76 mm/mm) versus 0.7 mm at 5 cm (0.34 mm/mm). Conclusion. Our finite-element model demonstrated that overtightening of the distal tibiofibular syndesmosis with medial fibular displacement can cause widening of the lateral clear space. Clinical relevance. The results suggest that screws placed farther from the plafond widen the lateral clear space to a lesser degree, which may be advantageous during surgical fixation to prevent clear space widening and increased tibiotalar contact forces.