Poor Adherence to Oral Psychiatric Medication in Adults with Depression: Psychological Reactance May Have Specific Effects in Depression

Objective: Medication adherence in psychiatric disorders, including depression, may be influenced by 6 self-reported dimensions: 1) high/low doctor health locus of control (HLOC), 2) high/low internal HLOC, 3) high/low psychological reactance, 4) pharmacophilia, 5) pharmacophobia, and 6) skepticism about a specific medication. This study in Spain, Argentina, and Venezuela included 521 outpatients with depression prescribed 920 psychiatric medications and 851 other psychiatric outpatients prescribed 1534 medications. Methods: Logistic regression models were completed in patients with depression and psychiatric controls. The dependent variable was adherence for each psychiatric medication (Sidorkiewicz Adherence Tool). The models provided adjusted odds ratios (ORs) of dichotomous independent variables: clinical variables, and 6 self-reported dimensions. Results: ORs significant in both diagnostic groups were: 1) pharmacophobia (OR=0.500 in depression, OR=0.599 in other patients), 2) pharmacophilia (respectively OR=1.51, OR=1.65), 3) treatment for 1 year (respectively OR=0.731, OR=0.608), 4) geriatric age (respectively OR=2.28, OR=3.02), and 5) skepticism about a specific medication (respectively OR=0.443, OR=0.569). Two ORs were significant in the depression group, but not in the controls: the country of Spain (OR=0.744), and high psychological reactance (OR=0.685). The study included 470 depression patients prescribed 510 antidepressants and 348 other patients prescribed 370 antidepressants. One OR was significant for antidepressant adherence in both groups: high psychological reactance (respectively OR=0.597, OR=0.561). Conclusions: All clinical studies using self-report include biases but the most important is lack of access to patients not coming for treatment. Future studies should further explore the specificity/commonality of these dimensions, particularly psychological reactance, in depression versus other psychiatric disorders.