Ileoproctostomy is preferred over ileoanal pull-through in patients with indeterminate colitis

J. H. Bodzin, S. N. Klein, S. G. Priest, A. Senagore

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

33 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A 15-year retrospective review was undertaken to evaluate the operative outcomes of patients with indeterminate colitis who were referred for rectal- sparing operations. Review of 95 consecutive patients operated for ulcerative colitis (UC) or indeterminate colitis (IC) revealed characteristics of IC in 13 patients. In the group as a whole, there were 45 females and 50 males; the average age was 33. A total of 64 patients had ileoanal pull-through (IAA). Analysis revealed that four of these patients had IC revealed by findings before operation in three patients and following the first stage of operation in one patient. Three of these four patients have subsequently required permanent ileostomy. Six patients who underwent IAA have subsequently demonstrated signs and symptoms of Crohn's disease (CD). All six have subsequently required ileostomy. Overall 10 patients with CD underwent IAA, and nine have required permanent ileostomy. Fourteen patients had ileorectal anastomosis (IRA) for UC or IC. IRA was performed for patients with IC in nine cases, and five patients with UC elected this operative option. Indications for IRA in patients with UC included obesity, 2; mental retardation, 1; advanced age, 1; and patient preference, 1. Of the patients with IC who underwent IRA, two have subsequently shown signs and symptoms of Crohn's disease. Overall, 14 of 14 patients who had IRA still have functioning IRA. None has required ileostomy. The poor results of IAA in patients with UC or IC subsequently shown to have CD have caused us to change our operative approach in patients with any question in the diagnosis of UC. The excellent results of IRA in patients with UC and IC have led us to perform this procedure in patients with a preoperative diagnosis of IC. Careful evaluation of patients with particular attention to subtle historical and physical findings, as well as specific advanced testing to differentiate patients with UC from those with IC or CD, is indicated.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)590-593
Number of pages4
JournalThe American surgeon
Volume61
Issue number7
StatePublished - 1995
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Colitis
Ulcerative Colitis
Ileostomy
Crohn Disease
Signs and Symptoms
Patient Preference

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery

Cite this

Bodzin, J. H., Klein, S. N., Priest, S. G., & Senagore, A. (1995). Ileoproctostomy is preferred over ileoanal pull-through in patients with indeterminate colitis. The American surgeon, 61(7), 590-593.

Ileoproctostomy is preferred over ileoanal pull-through in patients with indeterminate colitis. / Bodzin, J. H.; Klein, S. N.; Priest, S. G.; Senagore, A.

In: The American surgeon, Vol. 61, No. 7, 1995, p. 590-593.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Bodzin, JH, Klein, SN, Priest, SG & Senagore, A 1995, 'Ileoproctostomy is preferred over ileoanal pull-through in patients with indeterminate colitis', The American surgeon, vol. 61, no. 7, pp. 590-593.
Bodzin, J. H. ; Klein, S. N. ; Priest, S. G. ; Senagore, A. / Ileoproctostomy is preferred over ileoanal pull-through in patients with indeterminate colitis. In: The American surgeon. 1995 ; Vol. 61, No. 7. pp. 590-593.
@article{5ae60e3a2f934ee6b3af0fc378fd5f39,
title = "Ileoproctostomy is preferred over ileoanal pull-through in patients with indeterminate colitis",
abstract = "A 15-year retrospective review was undertaken to evaluate the operative outcomes of patients with indeterminate colitis who were referred for rectal- sparing operations. Review of 95 consecutive patients operated for ulcerative colitis (UC) or indeterminate colitis (IC) revealed characteristics of IC in 13 patients. In the group as a whole, there were 45 females and 50 males; the average age was 33. A total of 64 patients had ileoanal pull-through (IAA). Analysis revealed that four of these patients had IC revealed by findings before operation in three patients and following the first stage of operation in one patient. Three of these four patients have subsequently required permanent ileostomy. Six patients who underwent IAA have subsequently demonstrated signs and symptoms of Crohn's disease (CD). All six have subsequently required ileostomy. Overall 10 patients with CD underwent IAA, and nine have required permanent ileostomy. Fourteen patients had ileorectal anastomosis (IRA) for UC or IC. IRA was performed for patients with IC in nine cases, and five patients with UC elected this operative option. Indications for IRA in patients with UC included obesity, 2; mental retardation, 1; advanced age, 1; and patient preference, 1. Of the patients with IC who underwent IRA, two have subsequently shown signs and symptoms of Crohn's disease. Overall, 14 of 14 patients who had IRA still have functioning IRA. None has required ileostomy. The poor results of IAA in patients with UC or IC subsequently shown to have CD have caused us to change our operative approach in patients with any question in the diagnosis of UC. The excellent results of IRA in patients with UC and IC have led us to perform this procedure in patients with a preoperative diagnosis of IC. Careful evaluation of patients with particular attention to subtle historical and physical findings, as well as specific advanced testing to differentiate patients with UC from those with IC or CD, is indicated.",
author = "Bodzin, {J. H.} and Klein, {S. N.} and Priest, {S. G.} and A. Senagore",
year = "1995",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "61",
pages = "590--593",
journal = "The American surgeon",
issn = "0003-1348",
publisher = "Southeastern Surgical Congress",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ileoproctostomy is preferred over ileoanal pull-through in patients with indeterminate colitis

AU - Bodzin, J. H.

AU - Klein, S. N.

AU - Priest, S. G.

AU - Senagore, A.

PY - 1995

Y1 - 1995

N2 - A 15-year retrospective review was undertaken to evaluate the operative outcomes of patients with indeterminate colitis who were referred for rectal- sparing operations. Review of 95 consecutive patients operated for ulcerative colitis (UC) or indeterminate colitis (IC) revealed characteristics of IC in 13 patients. In the group as a whole, there were 45 females and 50 males; the average age was 33. A total of 64 patients had ileoanal pull-through (IAA). Analysis revealed that four of these patients had IC revealed by findings before operation in three patients and following the first stage of operation in one patient. Three of these four patients have subsequently required permanent ileostomy. Six patients who underwent IAA have subsequently demonstrated signs and symptoms of Crohn's disease (CD). All six have subsequently required ileostomy. Overall 10 patients with CD underwent IAA, and nine have required permanent ileostomy. Fourteen patients had ileorectal anastomosis (IRA) for UC or IC. IRA was performed for patients with IC in nine cases, and five patients with UC elected this operative option. Indications for IRA in patients with UC included obesity, 2; mental retardation, 1; advanced age, 1; and patient preference, 1. Of the patients with IC who underwent IRA, two have subsequently shown signs and symptoms of Crohn's disease. Overall, 14 of 14 patients who had IRA still have functioning IRA. None has required ileostomy. The poor results of IAA in patients with UC or IC subsequently shown to have CD have caused us to change our operative approach in patients with any question in the diagnosis of UC. The excellent results of IRA in patients with UC and IC have led us to perform this procedure in patients with a preoperative diagnosis of IC. Careful evaluation of patients with particular attention to subtle historical and physical findings, as well as specific advanced testing to differentiate patients with UC from those with IC or CD, is indicated.

AB - A 15-year retrospective review was undertaken to evaluate the operative outcomes of patients with indeterminate colitis who were referred for rectal- sparing operations. Review of 95 consecutive patients operated for ulcerative colitis (UC) or indeterminate colitis (IC) revealed characteristics of IC in 13 patients. In the group as a whole, there were 45 females and 50 males; the average age was 33. A total of 64 patients had ileoanal pull-through (IAA). Analysis revealed that four of these patients had IC revealed by findings before operation in three patients and following the first stage of operation in one patient. Three of these four patients have subsequently required permanent ileostomy. Six patients who underwent IAA have subsequently demonstrated signs and symptoms of Crohn's disease (CD). All six have subsequently required ileostomy. Overall 10 patients with CD underwent IAA, and nine have required permanent ileostomy. Fourteen patients had ileorectal anastomosis (IRA) for UC or IC. IRA was performed for patients with IC in nine cases, and five patients with UC elected this operative option. Indications for IRA in patients with UC included obesity, 2; mental retardation, 1; advanced age, 1; and patient preference, 1. Of the patients with IC who underwent IRA, two have subsequently shown signs and symptoms of Crohn's disease. Overall, 14 of 14 patients who had IRA still have functioning IRA. None has required ileostomy. The poor results of IAA in patients with UC or IC subsequently shown to have CD have caused us to change our operative approach in patients with any question in the diagnosis of UC. The excellent results of IRA in patients with UC and IC have led us to perform this procedure in patients with a preoperative diagnosis of IC. Careful evaluation of patients with particular attention to subtle historical and physical findings, as well as specific advanced testing to differentiate patients with UC from those with IC or CD, is indicated.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0029046724&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0029046724&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 61

SP - 590

EP - 593

JO - The American surgeon

JF - The American surgeon

SN - 0003-1348

IS - 7

ER -