Surgical referral coordination from a first-level hospital

A prospective case study from rural Nepal

Matthew Fleming, Caroline King, Sindhya Rajeev, Ashma Baruwal, Dan Schwarz, Ryan Schwarz, Nirajan Khadka, Sami Pande, Sumesh Khanal, Bibhav Acharya, Adia Benton, Selwyn O. Rogers, Maria Panizales, David Gyorki, Heather McGee, David Shaye, Duncan Maru

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Patients in isolated rural communities typically lack access to surgical care. It is not feasible for most rural first-level hospitals to provide a full suite of surgical specialty services. Comprehensive surgical care thus depends on referral systems. There is minimal literature, however, on the functioning of such systems. Methods: We undertook a prospective case study of the referral and care coordination process for cardiac, orthopedic, plastic, gynecologic, and general surgical conditions at a district hospital in rural Nepal from 2012 to 2014. We assessed the referral process using the World Health Organization's Health Systems Framework. Results: We followed the initial 292 patients referred for surgical services in the program. 152 patients (52%) received surgery and four (1%) suffered a complication (three deaths and one patient reported complication). The three most common types of surgery performed were: orthopedics (43%), general (32%), and plastics (10%). The average direct and indirect cost per patient referred, including food, transportation, lodging, medications, diagnostic examinations, treatments, and human resources was US840, which was over 1.5 times the local district's per capita income. We identified and mapped challenges according to the World Health Organization's Health Systems Framework. Given the requirement of intensive human capital, poor quality control of surgical services, and the overall costs of the program, hospital leadership decided to terminate the referral coordination program and continue to build local surgical capacity. Conclusion: The results of our case study provide some context into the challenges of rural surgical referral systems. The high relative costs to the system and challenges in accountability rendered the program untenable for the implementing organization.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number676
JournalBMC Health Services Research
Volume17
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 25 2017
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Nepal
Referral and Consultation
Prospective Studies
Plastics
Orthopedics
Surgical Specialties
Costs and Cost Analysis
District Hospitals
Hospital Costs
Social Responsibility
Health
Rural Population
Quality Control
Economics
Organizations
Food

Keywords

  • Case management
  • Community health worker
  • Developing countries
  • Disease management
  • General surgery
  • Global health
  • Nepal
  • Referral and consultation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health Policy

Cite this

Surgical referral coordination from a first-level hospital : A prospective case study from rural Nepal. / Fleming, Matthew; King, Caroline; Rajeev, Sindhya; Baruwal, Ashma; Schwarz, Dan; Schwarz, Ryan; Khadka, Nirajan; Pande, Sami; Khanal, Sumesh; Acharya, Bibhav; Benton, Adia; Rogers, Selwyn O.; Panizales, Maria; Gyorki, David; McGee, Heather; Shaye, David; Maru, Duncan.

In: BMC Health Services Research, Vol. 17, No. 1, 676, 25.09.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Fleming, M, King, C, Rajeev, S, Baruwal, A, Schwarz, D, Schwarz, R, Khadka, N, Pande, S, Khanal, S, Acharya, B, Benton, A, Rogers, SO, Panizales, M, Gyorki, D, McGee, H, Shaye, D & Maru, D 2017, 'Surgical referral coordination from a first-level hospital: A prospective case study from rural Nepal', BMC Health Services Research, vol. 17, no. 1, 676. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-017-2624-2
Fleming, Matthew ; King, Caroline ; Rajeev, Sindhya ; Baruwal, Ashma ; Schwarz, Dan ; Schwarz, Ryan ; Khadka, Nirajan ; Pande, Sami ; Khanal, Sumesh ; Acharya, Bibhav ; Benton, Adia ; Rogers, Selwyn O. ; Panizales, Maria ; Gyorki, David ; McGee, Heather ; Shaye, David ; Maru, Duncan. / Surgical referral coordination from a first-level hospital : A prospective case study from rural Nepal. In: BMC Health Services Research. 2017 ; Vol. 17, No. 1.
@article{9176d4c1ce364428b7467875549d0f07,
title = "Surgical referral coordination from a first-level hospital: A prospective case study from rural Nepal",
abstract = "Background: Patients in isolated rural communities typically lack access to surgical care. It is not feasible for most rural first-level hospitals to provide a full suite of surgical specialty services. Comprehensive surgical care thus depends on referral systems. There is minimal literature, however, on the functioning of such systems. Methods: We undertook a prospective case study of the referral and care coordination process for cardiac, orthopedic, plastic, gynecologic, and general surgical conditions at a district hospital in rural Nepal from 2012 to 2014. We assessed the referral process using the World Health Organization's Health Systems Framework. Results: We followed the initial 292 patients referred for surgical services in the program. 152 patients (52{\%}) received surgery and four (1{\%}) suffered a complication (three deaths and one patient reported complication). The three most common types of surgery performed were: orthopedics (43{\%}), general (32{\%}), and plastics (10{\%}). The average direct and indirect cost per patient referred, including food, transportation, lodging, medications, diagnostic examinations, treatments, and human resources was US840, which was over 1.5 times the local district's per capita income. We identified and mapped challenges according to the World Health Organization's Health Systems Framework. Given the requirement of intensive human capital, poor quality control of surgical services, and the overall costs of the program, hospital leadership decided to terminate the referral coordination program and continue to build local surgical capacity. Conclusion: The results of our case study provide some context into the challenges of rural surgical referral systems. The high relative costs to the system and challenges in accountability rendered the program untenable for the implementing organization.",
keywords = "Case management, Community health worker, Developing countries, Disease management, General surgery, Global health, Nepal, Referral and consultation",
author = "Matthew Fleming and Caroline King and Sindhya Rajeev and Ashma Baruwal and Dan Schwarz and Ryan Schwarz and Nirajan Khadka and Sami Pande and Sumesh Khanal and Bibhav Acharya and Adia Benton and Rogers, {Selwyn O.} and Maria Panizales and David Gyorki and Heather McGee and David Shaye and Duncan Maru",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
day = "25",
doi = "10.1186/s12913-017-2624-2",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "17",
journal = "BMC Health Services Research",
issn = "1472-6963",
publisher = "BioMed Central",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Surgical referral coordination from a first-level hospital

T2 - A prospective case study from rural Nepal

AU - Fleming, Matthew

AU - King, Caroline

AU - Rajeev, Sindhya

AU - Baruwal, Ashma

AU - Schwarz, Dan

AU - Schwarz, Ryan

AU - Khadka, Nirajan

AU - Pande, Sami

AU - Khanal, Sumesh

AU - Acharya, Bibhav

AU - Benton, Adia

AU - Rogers, Selwyn O.

AU - Panizales, Maria

AU - Gyorki, David

AU - McGee, Heather

AU - Shaye, David

AU - Maru, Duncan

PY - 2017/9/25

Y1 - 2017/9/25

N2 - Background: Patients in isolated rural communities typically lack access to surgical care. It is not feasible for most rural first-level hospitals to provide a full suite of surgical specialty services. Comprehensive surgical care thus depends on referral systems. There is minimal literature, however, on the functioning of such systems. Methods: We undertook a prospective case study of the referral and care coordination process for cardiac, orthopedic, plastic, gynecologic, and general surgical conditions at a district hospital in rural Nepal from 2012 to 2014. We assessed the referral process using the World Health Organization's Health Systems Framework. Results: We followed the initial 292 patients referred for surgical services in the program. 152 patients (52%) received surgery and four (1%) suffered a complication (three deaths and one patient reported complication). The three most common types of surgery performed were: orthopedics (43%), general (32%), and plastics (10%). The average direct and indirect cost per patient referred, including food, transportation, lodging, medications, diagnostic examinations, treatments, and human resources was US840, which was over 1.5 times the local district's per capita income. We identified and mapped challenges according to the World Health Organization's Health Systems Framework. Given the requirement of intensive human capital, poor quality control of surgical services, and the overall costs of the program, hospital leadership decided to terminate the referral coordination program and continue to build local surgical capacity. Conclusion: The results of our case study provide some context into the challenges of rural surgical referral systems. The high relative costs to the system and challenges in accountability rendered the program untenable for the implementing organization.

AB - Background: Patients in isolated rural communities typically lack access to surgical care. It is not feasible for most rural first-level hospitals to provide a full suite of surgical specialty services. Comprehensive surgical care thus depends on referral systems. There is minimal literature, however, on the functioning of such systems. Methods: We undertook a prospective case study of the referral and care coordination process for cardiac, orthopedic, plastic, gynecologic, and general surgical conditions at a district hospital in rural Nepal from 2012 to 2014. We assessed the referral process using the World Health Organization's Health Systems Framework. Results: We followed the initial 292 patients referred for surgical services in the program. 152 patients (52%) received surgery and four (1%) suffered a complication (three deaths and one patient reported complication). The three most common types of surgery performed were: orthopedics (43%), general (32%), and plastics (10%). The average direct and indirect cost per patient referred, including food, transportation, lodging, medications, diagnostic examinations, treatments, and human resources was US840, which was over 1.5 times the local district's per capita income. We identified and mapped challenges according to the World Health Organization's Health Systems Framework. Given the requirement of intensive human capital, poor quality control of surgical services, and the overall costs of the program, hospital leadership decided to terminate the referral coordination program and continue to build local surgical capacity. Conclusion: The results of our case study provide some context into the challenges of rural surgical referral systems. The high relative costs to the system and challenges in accountability rendered the program untenable for the implementing organization.

KW - Case management

KW - Community health worker

KW - Developing countries

KW - Disease management

KW - General surgery

KW - Global health

KW - Nepal

KW - Referral and consultation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85029856474&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85029856474&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/s12913-017-2624-2

DO - 10.1186/s12913-017-2624-2

M3 - Article

VL - 17

JO - BMC Health Services Research

JF - BMC Health Services Research

SN - 1472-6963

IS - 1

M1 - 676

ER -