The Effect of Autocorrelation on the Results of Visually Analyzing Data from Single-Subject Designs

Minoo K. Bengali, Kenneth Ottenbacher

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

18 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective. Single-subject research designs are used to conduct clinical research and outcome evaluation in occupational therapy. Confusion exists regarding the best method to analyze and interpret single-subject data. Method. One hundred graphs displaying the results of published single-subject research were examined to determine the influence of autocorrelation on the visual inferences made by the original investigators. The graphs were selected from 20 articles published over 10 years in seven rehabilitation journals. The data were extrapolated and lag 1 autocorrelation coefficients computed for both the baseline and treatment phases. Results. Data analysis focused on two issues: (a) whether a relationship existed between the amount of autocorrelation present in a graph and the conclusion on the basis of visual analysis and (b) whether the amount of autocorrelation varied across different phases of the single-subject graphs. When a significant degree of autocorrelation was present, research ers using visual analysis were more likely to conclude that there was no clinically significant change in performance. Autocorrelation values were significantly higher in the treatment phases of the single-subject designs. Conclusion. Additional research is needed to establish a set of decision rules to assist clinicians in using visual analysis to evaluate the results of single-subject research.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)650-655
Number of pages6
JournalAmerican Journal of Occupational Therapy
Volume52
Issue number8
StatePublished - Sep 1998

Fingerprint

Research
Occupational Therapy
Research Design
Rehabilitation
Research Personnel
Outcome Assessment (Health Care)
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Research design
  • Single subject research

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Rehabilitation
  • Health Professions(all)

Cite this

The Effect of Autocorrelation on the Results of Visually Analyzing Data from Single-Subject Designs. / Bengali, Minoo K.; Ottenbacher, Kenneth.

In: American Journal of Occupational Therapy, Vol. 52, No. 8, 09.1998, p. 650-655.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{48ed5e93bba8486fa09cfc74d66afbaf,
title = "The Effect of Autocorrelation on the Results of Visually Analyzing Data from Single-Subject Designs",
abstract = "Objective. Single-subject research designs are used to conduct clinical research and outcome evaluation in occupational therapy. Confusion exists regarding the best method to analyze and interpret single-subject data. Method. One hundred graphs displaying the results of published single-subject research were examined to determine the influence of autocorrelation on the visual inferences made by the original investigators. The graphs were selected from 20 articles published over 10 years in seven rehabilitation journals. The data were extrapolated and lag 1 autocorrelation coefficients computed for both the baseline and treatment phases. Results. Data analysis focused on two issues: (a) whether a relationship existed between the amount of autocorrelation present in a graph and the conclusion on the basis of visual analysis and (b) whether the amount of autocorrelation varied across different phases of the single-subject graphs. When a significant degree of autocorrelation was present, research ers using visual analysis were more likely to conclude that there was no clinically significant change in performance. Autocorrelation values were significantly higher in the treatment phases of the single-subject designs. Conclusion. Additional research is needed to establish a set of decision rules to assist clinicians in using visual analysis to evaluate the results of single-subject research.",
keywords = "Research design, Single subject research",
author = "Bengali, {Minoo K.} and Kenneth Ottenbacher",
year = "1998",
month = "9",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "52",
pages = "650--655",
journal = "American Journal of Occupational Therapy",
issn = "0272-9490",
publisher = "American Occupational Therapy Association, Inc",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Effect of Autocorrelation on the Results of Visually Analyzing Data from Single-Subject Designs

AU - Bengali, Minoo K.

AU - Ottenbacher, Kenneth

PY - 1998/9

Y1 - 1998/9

N2 - Objective. Single-subject research designs are used to conduct clinical research and outcome evaluation in occupational therapy. Confusion exists regarding the best method to analyze and interpret single-subject data. Method. One hundred graphs displaying the results of published single-subject research were examined to determine the influence of autocorrelation on the visual inferences made by the original investigators. The graphs were selected from 20 articles published over 10 years in seven rehabilitation journals. The data were extrapolated and lag 1 autocorrelation coefficients computed for both the baseline and treatment phases. Results. Data analysis focused on two issues: (a) whether a relationship existed between the amount of autocorrelation present in a graph and the conclusion on the basis of visual analysis and (b) whether the amount of autocorrelation varied across different phases of the single-subject graphs. When a significant degree of autocorrelation was present, research ers using visual analysis were more likely to conclude that there was no clinically significant change in performance. Autocorrelation values were significantly higher in the treatment phases of the single-subject designs. Conclusion. Additional research is needed to establish a set of decision rules to assist clinicians in using visual analysis to evaluate the results of single-subject research.

AB - Objective. Single-subject research designs are used to conduct clinical research and outcome evaluation in occupational therapy. Confusion exists regarding the best method to analyze and interpret single-subject data. Method. One hundred graphs displaying the results of published single-subject research were examined to determine the influence of autocorrelation on the visual inferences made by the original investigators. The graphs were selected from 20 articles published over 10 years in seven rehabilitation journals. The data were extrapolated and lag 1 autocorrelation coefficients computed for both the baseline and treatment phases. Results. Data analysis focused on two issues: (a) whether a relationship existed between the amount of autocorrelation present in a graph and the conclusion on the basis of visual analysis and (b) whether the amount of autocorrelation varied across different phases of the single-subject graphs. When a significant degree of autocorrelation was present, research ers using visual analysis were more likely to conclude that there was no clinically significant change in performance. Autocorrelation values were significantly higher in the treatment phases of the single-subject designs. Conclusion. Additional research is needed to establish a set of decision rules to assist clinicians in using visual analysis to evaluate the results of single-subject research.

KW - Research design

KW - Single subject research

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0032159514&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0032159514&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 9739399

AN - SCOPUS:0032159514

VL - 52

SP - 650

EP - 655

JO - American Journal of Occupational Therapy

JF - American Journal of Occupational Therapy

SN - 0272-9490

IS - 8

ER -