While you were sleepwalking

Science and neurobiology of sleep disorders & the enigma of legal responsibility of violence during parasomnia

Shreeya Popat, William Winslade

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In terms of medical science and legal responsibility, the sleep disorder category of parasomnias, chiefly REM sleep behavior disorder and somnambulism, pose an enigmatic dilemma. During an episode of parasomnia, individuals are neither awake nor aware, but their actions appear conscious. As these actions move beyond the innocuous, such as eating and blurting out embarrassing information, and enter the realm of rape and homicide, their degree of importance and relevance increases exponentially. Parasomnias that result in illegal activity, particularly violence, are puzzling phenomena for medicine and the law. Via a review of the pertinent medical literature, a general overview of the current scientific knowledge of parasomnias will be provided. Though this knowledge is far from complete, it can provide some neurobiological information about the nature of parasomnia, including conclusions about a sleepwalker’s level of intention as well as factors that predispose one to such episodes. Although a parasomniac’s complete lack of consciousness warrants acquittal from criminal liability, it does not exclude responsibility for subjecting oneself to exacerbating factors that result in these violent parasomnias. Individuals should be held accountable if they could be expected to control these factors. In addition, they should undergo appropriate treatment and management in order to prevent future parasomnia behaviors. Establishing a legal defense for parasomnia will prove difficult due to the strong potential for malingering, so specific criteria will be outlined in order to distinguish between true and fraudulent claims of crimes committed during parasomniac states.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)203-214
Number of pages12
JournalNeuroethics
Volume8
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 24 2015

Fingerprint

Somnambulism
Parasomnias
Neurobiology
Violence
REM Sleep Behavior Disorder
Malingering
Rape
Sleep Wake Disorders
Homicide
Crime
Consciousness
Eating
Medicine

Keywords

  • Crime
  • Parasomnias
  • Sleep arousal disorders
  • Somnambulism
  • Violence

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health Policy
  • Neurology
  • Psychiatry and Mental health

Cite this

While you were sleepwalking : Science and neurobiology of sleep disorders & the enigma of legal responsibility of violence during parasomnia. / Popat, Shreeya; Winslade, William.

In: Neuroethics, Vol. 8, No. 2, 24.04.2015, p. 203-214.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{6652fb054f4e4ef28a3d1c5328eebfbc,
title = "While you were sleepwalking: Science and neurobiology of sleep disorders & the enigma of legal responsibility of violence during parasomnia",
abstract = "In terms of medical science and legal responsibility, the sleep disorder category of parasomnias, chiefly REM sleep behavior disorder and somnambulism, pose an enigmatic dilemma. During an episode of parasomnia, individuals are neither awake nor aware, but their actions appear conscious. As these actions move beyond the innocuous, such as eating and blurting out embarrassing information, and enter the realm of rape and homicide, their degree of importance and relevance increases exponentially. Parasomnias that result in illegal activity, particularly violence, are puzzling phenomena for medicine and the law. Via a review of the pertinent medical literature, a general overview of the current scientific knowledge of parasomnias will be provided. Though this knowledge is far from complete, it can provide some neurobiological information about the nature of parasomnia, including conclusions about a sleepwalker’s level of intention as well as factors that predispose one to such episodes. Although a parasomniac’s complete lack of consciousness warrants acquittal from criminal liability, it does not exclude responsibility for subjecting oneself to exacerbating factors that result in these violent parasomnias. Individuals should be held accountable if they could be expected to control these factors. In addition, they should undergo appropriate treatment and management in order to prevent future parasomnia behaviors. Establishing a legal defense for parasomnia will prove difficult due to the strong potential for malingering, so specific criteria will be outlined in order to distinguish between true and fraudulent claims of crimes committed during parasomniac states.",
keywords = "Crime, Parasomnias, Sleep arousal disorders, Somnambulism, Violence",
author = "Shreeya Popat and William Winslade",
year = "2015",
month = "4",
day = "24",
doi = "10.1007/s12152-015-9229-4",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "8",
pages = "203--214",
journal = "Neuroethics",
issn = "1874-5490",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - While you were sleepwalking

T2 - Science and neurobiology of sleep disorders & the enigma of legal responsibility of violence during parasomnia

AU - Popat, Shreeya

AU - Winslade, William

PY - 2015/4/24

Y1 - 2015/4/24

N2 - In terms of medical science and legal responsibility, the sleep disorder category of parasomnias, chiefly REM sleep behavior disorder and somnambulism, pose an enigmatic dilemma. During an episode of parasomnia, individuals are neither awake nor aware, but their actions appear conscious. As these actions move beyond the innocuous, such as eating and blurting out embarrassing information, and enter the realm of rape and homicide, their degree of importance and relevance increases exponentially. Parasomnias that result in illegal activity, particularly violence, are puzzling phenomena for medicine and the law. Via a review of the pertinent medical literature, a general overview of the current scientific knowledge of parasomnias will be provided. Though this knowledge is far from complete, it can provide some neurobiological information about the nature of parasomnia, including conclusions about a sleepwalker’s level of intention as well as factors that predispose one to such episodes. Although a parasomniac’s complete lack of consciousness warrants acquittal from criminal liability, it does not exclude responsibility for subjecting oneself to exacerbating factors that result in these violent parasomnias. Individuals should be held accountable if they could be expected to control these factors. In addition, they should undergo appropriate treatment and management in order to prevent future parasomnia behaviors. Establishing a legal defense for parasomnia will prove difficult due to the strong potential for malingering, so specific criteria will be outlined in order to distinguish between true and fraudulent claims of crimes committed during parasomniac states.

AB - In terms of medical science and legal responsibility, the sleep disorder category of parasomnias, chiefly REM sleep behavior disorder and somnambulism, pose an enigmatic dilemma. During an episode of parasomnia, individuals are neither awake nor aware, but their actions appear conscious. As these actions move beyond the innocuous, such as eating and blurting out embarrassing information, and enter the realm of rape and homicide, their degree of importance and relevance increases exponentially. Parasomnias that result in illegal activity, particularly violence, are puzzling phenomena for medicine and the law. Via a review of the pertinent medical literature, a general overview of the current scientific knowledge of parasomnias will be provided. Though this knowledge is far from complete, it can provide some neurobiological information about the nature of parasomnia, including conclusions about a sleepwalker’s level of intention as well as factors that predispose one to such episodes. Although a parasomniac’s complete lack of consciousness warrants acquittal from criminal liability, it does not exclude responsibility for subjecting oneself to exacerbating factors that result in these violent parasomnias. Individuals should be held accountable if they could be expected to control these factors. In addition, they should undergo appropriate treatment and management in order to prevent future parasomnia behaviors. Establishing a legal defense for parasomnia will prove difficult due to the strong potential for malingering, so specific criteria will be outlined in order to distinguish between true and fraudulent claims of crimes committed during parasomniac states.

KW - Crime

KW - Parasomnias

KW - Sleep arousal disorders

KW - Somnambulism

KW - Violence

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84938291692&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84938291692&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s12152-015-9229-4

DO - 10.1007/s12152-015-9229-4

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 203

EP - 214

JO - Neuroethics

JF - Neuroethics

SN - 1874-5490

IS - 2

ER -